Unraid vs proxmox reddit. Valheim; Genshin Impact; .

Unraid vs proxmox reddit It sounds like you don't have the drives or case to set up a proper Unraid server, so start with a Proxmox setup. Probably mostly windows and Ubuntu VMs, plus I’d like to start playing with Truenas Scale is storage biased, Proxmox and unRaid are more meant for managed VMs and containers. I like Unraid the most, then TrueNAS, then OMV. 8 went cold and I don’t see anything about it in the release notes. Though I guess thats more related to The one for certain is home assistant is, and everyone seems to mention running home assistant on proxmox (I’ve been out of custom pcs and virtualization forever) I also have some ancient and full synology to retire, and figured a good time to get Unraid up and running as well. unraid will allow you to use mixed drive sizes, supports adding one drive to expand the array, runs standard docker and Drives. You also may have issues on double nested containers. If I need an visual Studio, I can add a docker from the Apps section. What i want to do: running my own small web applications plex (for movies) pi hole private data storage For UnRAID, a decent case and PSU, unless you can find a good bargain, will run you about $200-250. Now if your wanting to also offload your pictures and other things. Other possible factors: OMV is free but unraid has a cost $60 usd. Couldn’t be more happy. Proxmox and Kubernetes aren't the same thing, but they fill similar roles in terms of self-hosting. I had that setup for a while along with a lot of the downloader apps in windows. If you prioritize advanced virtualization features, Server Base OS - unraid, proxmox, truenas, else upvotes · comments. Discussion Hey everyone, I already have an unraid setup as my plex server and some file storage. Biggest difference is ZFS vs fake raid. It works great. I was curious what the major differences are between TrueNAS Scale vs. You could If you can swing two servers, it's the best of both worlds. I plan to basically have 1 VM that uses Ubuntu and docker compose and runs things like plex radar sonar, etc. on a second vm, i'd install dietpi or uptime-kuma or whatever. As a Debian native, the Proxmox subscription warning and ZFS license incompatibilities are speaking to my soul. I had an LXC Container for every service and a few VMs. If you want more flexibility proxmox and turenas vm This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Come and join us today! Members Online. Unraid is probably more user friendly for new folks learning, but will make you feel a bit limited as you become more advanced. If you don’t have a lot of disks and don’t plan on expanding, then the others look very appealing. I don’t have any Unraid exposure, so can not compare the platforms. Proxmox has way better vm management capabilities, native zfs and lxc containers are wonderful. A reddit dedicated to the profession of Computer System Administration. Then got bored again and gave Xcp-ng a spin. As mentioned above, Unraid is a Network-Attached Storage (NAS) operating system. Sort by: Best. Hopefully this helps someone with their research and isn't just an old man rambling at a cloud. However, windows vs unraid is apple to orange. I lean toward TrueNAS since it is the open-source option. AMD Radeon RX 6650 XT Passthrough to Win 11 VM I’ve been tempted to set it up again several times when trying to decide between shoehorning something into Unraid vs Proxmox. so many apps can't name them all. And yeah, it is the way I love it. I know a lot of people virtualize unraid under proxmox, the other View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. and once you're using the command line, the tooling for VMs and docker is going to be the same, the only differences might be the version of the tool and where certain configs are stored. Both are good choices. Then, on the same Proxmox server I run a Plex Server and NextCloud server on Ubuntu. I'm looking to build my first home server/NAS in the next few months and was wondering if anyone had any opinions on TrueNas Scale (not the same as TrueNas Core/FreeNas) vs Unraid. I will say that I do prefer Proxmox when VMs are in play but most things you can simply serve via docker containers on Unraid. Point is there are advantages to having an additional platform. IMO, it is better to run real hypervisor bare metal and virtualize storage in VM. The primary differentiation is that Unraid has it's own closed source, proprietary parity algorithm and webUI vs OMV which is effectively just a webUI that lets you install software. IIUC, this is similar to what Proxmox is doing (Debian + KVM). Since you're asking this question, it implies you don't have any real plans or defined reason for running a more robust level 2 hypervisor, like Proxmox. For my storage server, I intend for it to be primarily for hosting storage, and providing storage to other services and applications. It seems like they have some similar features in terms of running various apps/containers on them, and from what I can tell the main differences are ZFS on TrueNas and easier expandability on Unraid. This is for homelab experimentation, Proxmox vs. A better comparison would be truenas and unraid. all of them work very well. With this setup Proxmox updates were anxiety inducing - not knowing if a proxmox update would "break" the unraid+plopkexec combination. Can I suggest a crazy idea? you use Proxmox as your base OS with TrueNAS in a VM and all the drives attached to that. But all of these will serve you better running on bare metal, rather than virtualized within Proxmox. Depends on how you want to set up your server. Firstly, I'm completely new to Unraid (and Docker and Home Assistant for that matter). I'm migrating to a new Proxmox build with plans to run either TrueNAS or Unraid (since I already have the license purchased) virtualized with direct access to the hard drives STRICTLY for NAS/data storage (not running containers or apps) and running I used unraid for a long time then decided to switch to proxmox to try it out. Unraid is pretty similar to TrueNAS scale in the sense that both are NAS with container apps on top. Any thoughts? Use case: The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community Unraid seems to be a great option, with the ability to expand your pools later on. com with the ZFS community I have a lot of content and backups on my unRAID server and want the solution that works best for both Windows and Mac. Help Hi, I'm going round and round trying to decide on a Mini PC (1L or less) to play around with dockers and virtual machines. So if your workload suits the unraid array (write once read often) then unraid is very difficult to beat. So here is what I'm trying to accomplish as of right now. However, TrueNAS Scale and UnRAID are mainly developed as storage engines, so the hypervisor part of these products is like an additional but not the main feature. I would argue, that by not using Proxmox you have all your eggs in one basket. These are used for managing native Linux capabilities like virtual networking and Kernel-based Virtual Machines (KVMs). Proxmox, on the other hand, is a powerful virtualization This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. So pick your poison lol. Unraid charges you $59-129 depending on how many drives you install. ZFS has lots of advantages like snapshots, integrity, different caches and so on. ftp support nfs support smb support, home grown drop box, download hunter. What are the main differences between Unraid vs Proxmox? Unraid is a NAS solution with basic virtualization features that focuses on flexible storage management. I run Unraid inside of proxmox, no issues at all, great performance. Come and join us today! Well it seams like there isn't any special sauce to how unraid uses p vs e cores. Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible. The consensus among users varies depending on their needs and technical For me in the end Unraid was a winner for the following 2 reasons: Proxmox recommended setup is 3 drives before storage. Right now I do not understand though why people will run proxmox with 50 ubuntu server vms to host all these products that have been containerized inside docker. Wrt. I had a question about performance between running a VM through Unraid vs through Proxmox / ESXi. Discussion Hey all, New Homelabber here. starting with 2 drives. Add as you need. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party Windows vs Proxmox Since you are building a new box, I highly recommend trying Proxmox. ) Virtualizing UNraid on Proxmox works flawlessly - 4 cores and 8gb ram is plenty This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Why this vs. Unraid, TrueNAS and OMV are great NAS OS but not very flexible when used as a base OS for running some other VMs. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. r/Proxmox. Any suggestions? Related Topics Proxmox probably makes the most sense if for no other reason than the 40 bucks or whatever the entry license costs these days for unraid. I have unRAID setup to write all new files for my “data” share to the Cache Pool (NVME) which only gets moved to the Array (HDD) once a file is 30 days old. I'm still waiting for my nas case to come in, but, once it does, I plan on running Unraid as a proxmox vm. Not an issue either. Plus UnRAID license will be an additional $59 (up to 6 drives) or $89 (up to 12 drives). 2 port over for the cache drive. Help I have an old gaming computer intel core i5 (it has two 2TB HDDs, two 1TB HDDs and one 256 GB SSD) that I plan to convert to either a Proxmox or TrueNAS server. Scripts - Runs code in the unraid OS Plugins - Adds improvement to the unraid OS Docker Container - Runs program in a sand box that shares some resources with the Unraid OS. You can run FreeNAS on Proxmox along with Open Media Vault. Spaces as a storage solution, but it's a perfectly viable option, especially if you're more comfortable with Windows vs i am currently running a Server with Windows 10. I'm Looking to build a budget-ish Proxmox build (ideally sub $500? don't have a firm budget. Proxmox cannot natively run Docker containers, but it can run LXC containers. On the note of virtualization / being a hypervisor, based on unraids clean interface, and ease of assigning physical devices to a VM, I personally, would call unraid a Proxmox vs Unraid for VMs . Proxmox sure is a better hypervisor, no doubt about that. If your download and appdata are on the same pool, huge I/O writes will lock up your server. all eggs in one basket, Proxmox with Proxmox Backup Server is a really powerful combination which allows you to spin up a backup so quickly. Although ZFS has worked in xcp-ng since 2018, I feel like it is more of an afterthought vs how it feels more native in proxmox. Reply reply when restoring from backups is almost always inconvenient vs just Yay I finally maxed out my Unraid mobo today: max ram capacity, best CPU it can handle, every SATA port used, every PCIe lane in use r/Proxmox. HomeNetworking join leave 395,772 readers. For backups, Proxmox has a great tool called Proxmox Backup Server. I plan in running a whole lot of enterprise-y DevOps stuff on it however. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation in my little mind with my little experience and in an ideal world - i'd set up a second proxmox machine, manage both proxmox machines in one interface, setup a lightweight distro-vm (like dietpi), pass-through the iGPU, install docker and deploy a plex stack. (I think OMV can host VMs at least, I know Unraid and TrueNAS can. Ended up switching back within a week because unraid is just way easier to use for NAS, docker and VMs. So I do this exact thing and have no performance issues with my unraid vm or the physical drives that I passed through. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. UnRAID is better with storage. Unraid, on the other hand, is a solid NAS OS that includes Docker containers and KVM-based VMs. With that said yes Unraid is an excellent product with a solid feature set. When I changed to unraid I therefor try the docker Version. 10 VM running through Unraid, as well as Rclone as a plugin on Unraid. Proxmox pfSense 22. Community Applications will primarily provide 2 & 3. I've finally decided to move from Proxmox to Unraid and oh boy, the transition started out rough. Also another pro was that it was linux, and some of our staff is familiar with it's kernel and found it easy to install drbd in linux as oposed to bsd. Linus Tech Tips - My network is bigger than yours ;) January 27, 2024 at 10:21AM Zfs in proxmox vs VM . Then proxmox has its own set of SSDs in hardware raid for VMs. My take on Unraid vs Proxmox: Proxmox can do pretty much everything that Unraid can do, though it's slightly less user friendly. If Proxmox really wanted they can switch to Xen and preserve 99% of the functionality of their orchestration and administration software. It seems nuts to me that on the same physical box I would have my VMs After many, many weeks of debating and hundreds of Reddit posts. Reply reply The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. This subreddit has gone Stuck Newbie on Proxmox vs Unraid upvotes This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. The only thing native on the box is Samba, everything else is Docker swarm (arrs, Plex, websites, Heimdall, traefik, immich,netbox, cyberchef, paperless ngx, etc), and the occasional VM is in Proxmox (Kali as a full vm, comparing CasaOS/Cosmos/TiPi as proxmox containers, testing k8s as proxmox containers) The only people who shit on Unraid are the ones who don't want to pay for the OS. You can post now and register later. While Proxmox will allow you to install a NAS OS as a virtual machine, everything must be done inside of that NAS VM. Before During my research, I analyzed various Reddit discussions and articles comparing Proxmox, Unraid, and other home server operating systems. Unraid does storage better than anyone and also makes docker super easy with their appstore, it is a great gateway into docker. Currently her VMs use 4c/8t of the 10700k that's in my UnRAID host and would like to either keep similar specs or potentially add more if needed. And (following a You Tube video) I managed to get Home Assistant working as a VM. Proxmox is better at Vms. For immediate help and problem This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. TrueNAS/unraid can’t do clustering at the host level. With that in mind, should I install Ubuntu Server or Proxmox? I'm familiar enough with the Linux command line that Ubuntu doesn't scare me, but also like the simplicity Proxmox seems to offer when I know I'm only interested in container workloads. My TrueNAS server is an Intel Pentium G4600 system and my Unraid is an i5-8400. I started with a vm with docker on my NAS (unRAID) and then moved to a vm with docker on a proxmox server and now I run a smattering of single purpose VMS and lxc containers on proxmox because it made updating, running, backing up specifically things, observing things easier. Virtual Machine - Basically an independent computer for most practical purposes. Proxmox needs less reserved than Unraid, because unlike Unraid, Proxmox is only doing one thing- running VMs. Having used Proxmox, Unraid, and TrueNAS- My current pick is TrueNAS. The data pool setup alone would make me use unraid. I started experimenting with the trial for Unraid and wasn't super thrilled. Help UNRaid vs TrueNAS vs Ubuntu Server vs OMV This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Home Server and Virtualization Crossroads - Proxmox vs Unraid Getting the final components to build a NAS. I run as much as I can on Proxmox and use Unraid for slow / archive storage. With proxmox you have do it too. Unraid requires a passed through USB and the actual VM needs to boot plopkexec (to load the USB). But after all i have only 1 windows vm and 7-8 linux. If you're using something else as your hypervisor then you probably don't need Proxmox. I've successfully installed Unraid with a 'basic' license. Proxmox and which one I should pick. My decision would be Proxmox as host OS vs Unraid as a host OS. Gaming. Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! Members Online. NAS on Proxmox After a lot of pro/conning I have decided it makes much more sense in my case to let Proxmox own ZFS which eliminates TrueNAS or any of the other NAS projects which want to own the disk/controller. If you want a NAS, OMV or unRAID would be good starting points, granted unRAID is the most beginner friendly. Had a period of Proxmox in between that and been fiddling with Proxmox on and off for labbing too. Although, I will note- I was/still am a huge fan of Unraid's simplicity though. Proxmox handles nested virtualization like a pro. Unraid can be your level 2 hypervisor too. Unraid if you want to just have a device that works that you forget about. I dont need VMs (maybe 1 max to mess around) and don't need storage management since I have the NAS. Unraid – Network-Attached Storage Device. Windows Server vs Proxmox . . com with View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Advise on migrating VMs from Unraid to Proxmox upvotes This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. I'm trying to make up my mind between using proxmox and Windows Server for my Hypervisor. Or run Proxmox if your more of a GUI Unraid has a home assistant docker you can install and run it from a docket vs vm. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Minecraft; I'd also be interested in the other benefits of Unraid/Ubuntu being a lower profile OS as I only use the current setup with Prowlarr, Radarr, Sonarr and a Download/FTP Client. The NVR archives to Unraid using NFS. I've been running unraid on proxmox along side some other VMs for a number of months now and it's been working great (other than 12th gen iGPU passthrough which seems to be an everyone issue), and I'm looking to invest in a UPS. The biggest challenge for Unraid is bitrot, which is a type of data corruption that can occur over time due to disk failure or The transition to unraid should be fairly simple, start consolidating data across your disks, try to get at least one or more drives empty, move it to your unraid box, format, add it to the array, start moving data from your windows box, when you free up another disk, move that to unraid and so on. After some readings i thought it would be Proxmox, but now i found out how easy to use unraid is. Proxmox handles the heavy lifting for running other services, while Unraid takes care of the storage part. Whenever I try to pass the hba to the unraid VM proxmox loses sight of its boot disk and crashes out taking the VMs whose disks are on an iscsi target on NAS1 synology (unsurprising behaviour but I wanted to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. are standalone OSes that will manage their own storage. Proxmox is all about hosting other VM's/containers (hypervisor). This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Linus Tech Tips - I’m Keeping the World’s Biggest TV. Those both access the storage on the NAS. I have TRUENAS Scale VM in Proxmox. If you're looking for a Proxmox is great with managing VMs and containers. I have a bunch of media View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. UnRaid vs. Also the Unraid thread proposing adding the reset bug header fix for Vega to Unraid 6. Religion and Science - unRAID vs. 05 and iocrest i225-V quad NIC pass through r/unRAID. Also passed a M. I want to launch two VMs one for windows and one for linux that I can access remotely. I pass through the HBA controller ( and therefore the attached drives) to TrueNAS. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at Proxmox vs Unraid/Docker Centric Hypervisors Discussion I see everyone using proxmox and I have used and do use it for very specific things. I have NO drives for it yet, and I'm trying to decide between unRAID and Proxmox as the "host OS" for the VMs I'm going to run. Hey everyone! I'm looking to move to a ZFS based platform and figure the ZFS subreddit would be the least biased for this question. They’re all hypervisors anyway, you know. I don't need big gun for Proxmox im tired from servers. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's Can you tell me why you went to unraid from proxmox? Reply reply The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. Also, Proxmox is free. So possibly better for gaming vms. For critical data like home pics, I only use zfs. I was using btrfs for my cache drives, but there is apparently a long standing bug with the btrfs file system and cache pools. But it will take more work to get Docker going on proxmox, for example. However, using ZFS inside a VM can be complex due to the need for passing through entire disks to the VM for best practices. I'm just muddling my way through things. Something about setting up nginx for only local use that just didn't work as a container in unRAID. sub $400 would be great, but unrealistic) A few parts are being re-used which is helpful. Valheim; Genshin Impact; NUC vs TinyMiniMicro, TrueNAS Scale/Unraid/Proxmox . Proxmox vs XCP-NG Geekbench scores + some notes on overall experience Discussion I recently decided to switch my dedicated Plex machine to something more versatile, and started testing out some various hypervisors, including Proxmox, XCP-NG, ESXi, and Hyper-V. proxmox is a distro for running VMs, bit overkill if you're only going to run a handful of them but a good platform the learn the basics on. Proxmox Unraid Main purpose will be VM, some containers (Docker) and a storage function (was thinking about XPEnology so I can replace the physical one and stream my camera’s). Usually is Windows vs some Linux desktop distro or UnRaid vs Synology. I guess i could go with the lowest CPU with HD770 which is the 12500 (6c12t) which is the same as my existing 8700k but with the extra igpu horsepower. For immediate help and problem solving, The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. They don't even donate to the products/projects they do support. You don't NEED Windows for any of that. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. I doubt I'd use much of the app marketplace or hypervisor since I've got ProxMox and need multiple k3s clusters / more control. Well, Ubuntu Server, from what you named, will be the most optimal choice (but would need some tinkering). get reddit premium. Both are great. In fact have a few Docker VM clusters too. I don’t use unraid due to the cost, Truenas due to the forums, before I went for Proxmox I tried to research Truenas and I've been looking at Unraid and proxmox. Proxmox is more powerful when it comes to more advanced vm features, like snapshots, I'm not sure you can really compare proxmox and unraid for your use case, they are solving two separate problems. Now, if you only have a pool of 2 drives, then unraid will be more because of registration. r/unRAID. It’s a bit tricky and there are a few steps, but plenty of videos, blogs and Reddit posts to help. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at https://discourse. It is designed to be easy to use and expand, but it is not free. On point 1. Some users access them through apache guacamole that I have hosted on one of my synologys. Unraid vs Windows . 5" vs. Was thinking about unraid vs truenas for a NAS build; kind of leaning towards unraid for now. Convert existing ESXI server to Proxmox. Synology comments. The VM is going to be used by my friends when they are at my house and they'll stream to their laptops using parsec, what are the advantages and disadvantages of unraid compared to proxmox and vice versa? 2P cores with the 12700k vs 4E 13600k cores More power consumption with 13th gen during workloads, though at idle they seem to be the same I am retiring my proxmox server and moving to Unraid as I need a NAS, and am trying to lower my power consumption by having one machine using Unraid to also host my VMs and other services. Proxmox can. practicalzfs. Unraid machine vs. On Proxmox, I noticed that you can, as you can add in all the cores for the VM. Reddit; RSS Feed; Twitter; DISCLAIMER. Do Ryzen APU's work for hardware transcode in Plex yet? This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. ProxMox Unraid has cpu pinning, cpu isolation, cpu governor and the ability to pass through the boot gpu. TrueNAS Scale vs. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Also motherboard sound. I was not as big a fan of it was proxmox but it works fine as well. I was planning on using Unraid since I can add disks fairly ad-hoc but then they release Scale and it looks really nice. ProxMox plus Other? The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. I recently went through the headache of choosing the OS for my NAS again (rebuilding the pools and hardware) and made some inquiries here on Reddit on what to choose. The data/parity setup is much simpler to get going on unraid, as compared to the mergerfs/snapraid setup on OMV. Il do that on a separate linux box or use proxmox. You’re better off with unraid. And if you don't have RAM, then you'll need to add that, and probably need at least 2x8GB for 16GB total for probably another $60 or so. One area that unraid is quite mighty though is it's community. So i dont need Proxmox for linux vms . Both have their plus and minus. Proxmox/Esxi VM vs Unraid VM . I use proxmox for my local DC VM (another one runs on a Hetzner dedicated server and communicates with the local one via VPN), Kubernetes cluster (as a lab, 1 master, 2 nodes ), a coyote more VMs that I need, as well as an unRaid VM to which I pass through array and cache disks (as well as a virtual disk of 20GB to store application preferences View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. 3. Members Online. The UI is often not as friendly as Unraid's or Proxmox's too, since it expects a certain level of expertise I did not posses. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing I've narrowed things down to choosing between unRAID and TrueNAS Scale. Proxmox is absolutely rock-solid. Linus Tech Tips - This Review is Going to Make unraid (slackware) and proxmox (debian) are just linux distros with web interfaces. I have been using zfs with both Proxmox and Ubuntu server for years now. Proxmox - Unraid Alternative? (for my gaming use case) r/Proxmox. On the side I have a SFF machine running proxmox with my various VMs with a 10500. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at Before TrueNAS I ran Unraid as a VM too. I prefer running my VMs under Proxmox rather than under a bare-metal TrueNAS installation, simply because I like Proxmox's snapshot & backup mechanism better, plus, it allows me to backup TrueNAS's configuration in a seamless way (aka using the same mechanism I use with the other Proxmox VMs). So I am completely building a new server, with the hopes of building a powerhouse capable of 4+ 1080p streams/transcodes or an inhouse 4k stream/transcode. Truenas (Scale in in VM) is a superb NAS. Of course I understand some people will have specific use cases Unraid is easier to setup for plex and automatically downloading files from a server and what not. Reply reply WholesomeFluffa • Thanks! But I kinda expect the average user asking basic questions like docker vs vm to use the "default'". Proxmox? r/unRAID. Archived This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. WunderTech is a trade name of WunderTech, LLC. I've read so many discussions regarding whether to or not to virtualize. Can separate different apps on separate operating systems, so messing around with one won't wreck another Don't forget that a ton of docker users are utilizing something like This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. I was watching a video of a guy who was demonstrating how to create a VM, and I noticed something right away : you can not use all the CPU cores for the VM. i have 5 windows vm's and one ubuntu in unraid. if you're going to learn ansible, you'll want to be comfortable with the command line. e. For home users, in my opinion- unraid is just dead simple to configure, use, and setup your services. Unraid can do docker and VMs fine - a lot of my choices are related to hardware for me - i. I just want something that will easily get my services up and running. This is my A Proxmox host running a ZFS Mirrored SSD storage pool and a ZFS RaidZ Hard Drive storage pool with virtual "disks" formatted as BTRFS inside an OpenMediaVault VM. For immediate help and problem solving, If I move all unRAID Docker/VM’s directly into Proxmox the only thing unRAID really offers that Proxmox might not is my ability to use /mnt/user/ which has both Cache drive and Array drives. But it MAY work out of box on the newest unraid? Join the conversation. The biggest differences are- Unraid has its own “storage” system, which, works like raid, but, is not I am all for Proxmox, but I must say that I am tempted by unRaid for the builtin Docker management. i have tried proxmox and it is not as seamless as the hypervisor in unraid. At work we use Proxmox, in about 7 clusters, ranging from two nodes to 10. 1 for OS, 1 for VMs, 1 for ISOs. Unraid is easy, it generally "just works". What caused me to switch is I started running up against issues with Storage Spaces and liked the sound of Proxmox will allow me to learn something new, so proxmox it is. Ok, before anyone jumps in and tells me the obvious choice is Proxmox with TrueNAS or UNraid let me give some background information. " Im curious to know if that's still true bc I remember seeing something under "Check Filesystem Status" for the cache array. Proxmox is the choice for most when it comes to hosting virtual machines, however the psychical specs differ greatly from the other offerings as Proxmox hosts full fledged machines inside it while the others generally speaking run services directly. I recently purchased a Dell R510 with a H700 RAID card that I want to use primary as a NAS, but also be able to spin up VMs as needed to play with. The battle was Proxmox VS TrueNAS Scale. Linus Tech Tips - My network is bigger than yours ;) January 27, 2024 at 10:21AM youtube upvotes Proxmox vs. This subreddit has gone My current/old server setup is running Unraid so all of my Docker containers have run directly within Unraid for several years. The downside is I would not be able to add the drives to a ZFS pool when I purchase them down the line. To be exact, this will be running; Home assistant Pi-hole This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break Proxmox is a dedicated bare metal hypervisor, and so doesn't have the shortcuts/ease of use that Unraid does, but it's extremely capable. All in all, I would highly recommend proxmox. Proxmox is a full-fledged hypervisor that offers advanced virtualization capabilities and the creation of virtual machines Last night, I downloaded the USB tool from Unraid and decided to give it a try. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Minecraft; Virtualisation with Proxmox. Also, reinstalling proxmox is really fast if you really need to. We chouse proxmox because we wanted realtime storage replication, and cluster oriented features. I have a few proxmox VM instances running inside Proxmox. Need/want to learn something new that I'll build myself, which I really don't do anymore in these days of endless architecture meetings. My server (proxmox) runs a handful of LXC containers and a VM, throw in a small ZFS array and its using 30+GB of RAM. Yes, it costs for the registration, but there are 3 tiers. Proxmox is a Hypervisor OS which aims to have similar features as ESXi (and other enterprise Hypervisors). I went from five 2tb drives to a few 8tb and 10tb parity. If I wanted to virtualize the NAS and make it easier to manage file services, I would virtualize truenas and pass through an HBA to it. From your opinions what would you recommend, I just want something that can easily be setup and runs well. Unraid vs proxmox on minipc? Already have synology NAS and don't need VM management. I've been running Unraid for only a few months but have been impressed by parity and the adding of different drives. I currently a have Ubuntu 16. You will find few better, more helpful, devoted users anywhere on the entire internet. Using Unraid as a VM on Proxmox works well if you're mainly looking for storage. And- occasionally, I host a VM or two on it. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation In a previous post someone mentioned "Unraid doesn't use the data corruption correction capabilities of btrfs. Anyways, which would be a better solution, unraid or proxmox? I'm not looking for much else other than running two vms for gaming and like minded stuff, maybe setup a single vm I boot occasionally so my fiance can stream. For example, managing storage across the Proxmox and TrueNAS boundary might introduce additional complexity. 168 users here now. Unraid runs from a USB stick so you don't need to dedicate a sata port to the OS drive. In the comparison between Proxmox and Unraid, it is crucial to consider your specific needs before making a decision. Open comment sort options This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation Proxmox is a great solution if you want to quickly spin up discreet VMs. Leave out the “with Proxmox” idea, and any of these should be fine. I passed a whole HBA card through to unraid, so it’s getting basically hardware level access still. The VM (OS) runs on the SSD Pool and the "storage" is on the HD pool. While TrueNAS has ZFS and you don't have to have a USB as a critical part of your system. just Ubuntu Server bare metal? Read below, but just know that you could run both options for like a week or two and Only commenting to say that you're really talking apples and oranges here -- proxmox and ESXi are hypervisors on top of which you can run any storage VM (unraid, OMV, debian with roll-your-own snapraid), while unraid, freenas, windows, etc. However, if you wanna take a more straightforward route, get a proper hypervisor like Proxmox or ESXi and run NAS as a VM. I had been using Proxmox for well over a year now, I had it set up with ZFS and OMV was used for drive access. Because i have 3 Proxmox CTs an 5 docker conts including plex etc. I decided that i want to switch to an Linux based Server. they both use KVM virtualization. It excels at this. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at ZFS - unRAID vs TrueNAS . If you go the Unraid route I would recommend the following: Add r/Unraid to your Reddit follows as there is a ton of resources Add community apps to Unraid so you can access tons of templated dockers/apps for use id definitely say stick with proxmox abd learn it more deeply - truenas and unraid are nice for what they are but they arent proxmox - what it gives you that the others dont is the flexibility to run anything - containers (LXC) or VMs as well as VMs that themselves run Docker, you can put TrueNAS on as a VM in proxmox and either pass disks through or pass through controllers or Proxmox also allows me to spin up a VM for other things while keeping my main computer system free of clutter. i've also looked at unraid and ubuntu server I've asked the same in the unRAID subreddit, but would like to get more insights into the Proxmox specifics as well. If you are going to use Synology to store VMs/container, you should simply go with Proxmox. Under the hood proxmox and unraid use the same technology, so performance should be same. I also have NextCloud and Mealie on my Proxmox system as containers that the family uses. The deeper I get into things I begin to think that maybe I should just put Unraid as a VM under Proxmox and run both as a cluster. Proxmox Publications as early as V4 speak extensively about this capability for testing configurations. Proxmox even has a backup server now if that stuff tickles your pickle. Conclusion: Making an Informed Choice. Proxmox install and Docker into same hp mini and 60 watt Cpu:) I have tried windows, ubuntu, unraid 100 percent go unraid going forward stability, scalability . In my opinion, comparing managing the services as LXC containers in proxmox, versus comparing the docker containers in unraid- Unraid blows proxmox out of the water as far as container support. Run Proxmox with unRAID in a VM, and split the load in whatever way seems sensible Any preference between these two in your experience? Share Add a Comment. I do, however, have a good friend who runs a 4U home lab using it and it seems like both platforms accomplish basically the same thing, and do so with excellence. Not sure if better to go with xfs or zfs yet, so still researching that, but currently thinking how to run the unraid on the NAS. I have a Dell PowerEdge R720xd with 192GB of RAM and the PERC H710 controller. which would be better for me? comment sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment 14svfdqs The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. If you just want a server to run docker containers then I'd recommend a Debian lite server with Cockpit webUI. Proxmox vs TrueNAS CORE . truenas is ZFS based and truenas scale runs kubernetes, not docker. Personally I'd recommend Unraid both because you're starting out and because it's much easier to "set and forget" the important stuff. Sophos SG to XGS offer upvotes UnRaid vs TrueNAS (6 Its running a 10900K with a quadro rtx400 for transcoding. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Proxmox . I would be careful about running much in the way of containers on the unraid and take advantage of proxmox which is better at this than unraid. I run a NAS, so unraid doesn’t really hold a ton of benefit for me. Proxmox vs TrueNAS CORE vs TrueNAS SCALE - Help needed with choosing the hypervisor and guests . Welcome to the Unofficial iRacing Reddit ProxMox with TrueNas or Unraid This seems like a good option but, I keep finding comments about how this is a horrible setup because Unraid or Truenas can virtualize on their own. Proxmox stands out as a powerful hypervisor with advanced virtualization capabilities, while Unraid excels as a versatile network-attached storage solution. In a nutshell, Proxmox simply is a suite of utilities and a web UI running on top of minimal Debian 11. I'm not an expert in home servers by any stretch, but even I can manage Proxmox. However, after good use and extension of the trial, I ended up going Pro for Unraid. Your pool needs all drives vs. I'd say if you're just doing it for home use and not virtualizing production servers accross multiple nodes you'll have a wayyyy nicer experience on Unraid. I love the docker version of it. To add to what u/q1ung said, you can use things like Storage Spaces inside windows which can provide you that redundancy that you get with Unraid. ZFS Support: Proxmox supports ZFS, so you could manage ZFS either at the Proxmox level or within the TrueNAS VM. Ok, I need some help deciding which direction to go. use the following search parameters to narrow your results: subreddit:subreddit find submissions in "subreddit" author:username find submissions by "username" Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. On the downside, it has a little bit of a learning curve, you can mess up configs, and it will use more power. Ease of use with web dashboard i taught pc novices how to use it or i hide from them and they just copy whatever to share on another family windows pcs. It just streamlines so much and avoids the layer of abstraction you will find using something like Proxmox. com with First of all - TrueNAS Scale, Proxmox and UnRAID use the same hypervisor - KVM. However Proxmox is a lot more than just KVM, I argue than the supplementary bits like ZFS, OVS, Ceph and clustering are a lot more important than KVM or Xen. Proxmox if you want to tinker. I have been running UNRaid for about two years and I have constantly had issues with it freezing and having slow disk performance, even with a large SSD cache pool, as I write a lot of small files and extremely large files over 48GB. com with the ZFS community as well. But a lot more hoops to jump through to get the same results. NAS on Proxmox Stuck Newbie on Proxmox vs Unraid I am literally trying to get unRAID to boot into GUI mode in Proxmox, and reading this created a moment of levity was much appreciated. unraid works well for a hypervisor and is easy to get going. Running Proxmox inside of a virtual machine for practice? Unraid VM But- having used proxmox for quite some time now, and just picking up unraid over the weekend, I have been instantly sold on it, from the perspective of being able to easily fulfill my home-networking needs. Proxmox does support ZFS which is neat, and could benefit more from the insane amount of Ram that you have. You could technically cut out down Proxmox and Unraid are both virtualization and storage solutions, but they differ in their primary focus. Truenas scale or unraid. Two different targeted use cases. multi-cpu, tons of RAM, fewer drive slots / 2. Other than that, you can pretty much get everything else from Proxmox. TrueNAS Scale (in beta at the minute) will be better designed to run containers and VM's in the future. Proxmox vs unRAID? i plan on using my server for a NAS, heavily modded minecraft server, other game servers, media server, and a bunch of other inhome services. Both provide a cluster management abstraction over multiple physical machines, for example. Just make sure to set up direct access to your disks for Unraid to work best. Its also around 21 different docker containers. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. I run an UnRaid server on a Dell R630, dual Xenon, 96 GB RAM, 1TB SSD AND 10 2GB HDD unraid, proxmox, truenas, else The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. Come and join us This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. I'm planning on running a mix of Linux and That being said UnRaid is a weird NAS thing with VM support and Proxmox is a VM Host. FreeNAS (now TrueNAS) and Unraid are designed to be a NAS before hypervisor. TrueNAS/Unraid are NAS OS that can also run VMs and Containers. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. 5" in my Proxmox boxes. Not only are snapshots and backups nice, but Proxmox is the only hypervisor I've found that handles mapping devices (like USB dongles) really well. requires some forethought and planning to do it right. I've started setting up a home server. (Unraid lets me use both) No experience with Proxmox but I do run unRAID for 10+ years and smaller system with Portainer. There is a performance trade-off which is acceptable for testing. So hp mini 15x17 sm is all i needed:). btr fhzkg tvxiu xktww aqzfyy hgyx sagthpk ftq pxhqfjel awsk