Vym vs spyd reddit. I'm not a big fan of social media, but … SCHD vs.

Vym vs spyd reddit Or check it out in the app stores DGRO better growth over the last 5 years or VYM more stable? Share Sort by: Best. It can’t process it. An ETF that provides both dividend income and capital appreciation can help you reach your goal faster. Historical performance of SCHD vs VYM has I hope not to touch this money for a long time (10+ years). 5 standard deviations above the category average. SCHD edges out VYM with an annualized return of 11. Of course that doesn't mean a person has to pick one vs. The chart below compares the historical Sharpe Ratios of SPYD and VYM, offering insights into how both investments have performed under varying market conditions. It tracks the S&P 500 Low Volatility High Dividend Index, which is rebalanced semi-annually. 16%) contains primarily U. . 9 Dividend ETFs to Buy With $200 and Hold Forever 1/13/2025 - The Motley Fool. I'm not a big fan of social media, but SCHD vs. SCHD vs. In my portfolio I plan to have SCHD and VYM with VYM having a higher allocation, Sound good? Depending on your age consolidate to 1 total stock market or S&P 500 index fund, 1 international fund (if you aren’t content with the S&P’s international exposure), 1 bond fund (depending on your age you could skip this), and no more than 5-10% of your portfolio into individual stocks. If we look at rolling dividends from 2008 to the end of 2021, a period of time that included the great financial crisis as well as a global pandemic, we can see that VYM dividends grew at an annualized rate of 6. It fails in literally every metric. VYM heavily lags SCHD, DGRO, DGRW, SPY, VTI, etc in total returns. I am 50 SPYD Vs. SCHD - Expense Ratio Comparison SPYD has a 0. VIG is good and transparent screening. I see everyone talk about VOO, but why not VYM instead? The dividends are 50%+ higher (1. The main difference I’m looking at is the growth of vym in total return seems far higher. In 2008 and 09, VUM cut dividends due to finnancials, SCHD is heavy in finnancial but it gets balance 4 times per year. " It has it's own weighting criteria as well, which according to The current SPYD Sharpe Ratio is 1. Notice that the most recent 3 payable dates for VYM were 3/24, 6/24, and 9/22. SCHD’s dividend also increases an average of 14. Vym has a lower yield but made up for that with 1. It has a 2. OptimizedPortfolio. SPYD has a dividend yield of 4. 5%, not 4% or more. But that does not mean it could possibly have incremental total annual income like SCHD and VYM. 3% to 0. Fees are linear, performance not always. iShares Dividend ETF optimizedportfolio. (So pretty much Information Technology vs Health Care for the 2nd sector exposure). " It has it's own weighting criteria as well, which according to your statement would be "stock picking. As evidenced by their fund names, VYM and VIG utilize very different approaches when it comes to screening large-cap U. The top 10 holdings of each are quite different. VYM is a higher volume and great liquidity. but on reddit "the best" is what gets hyped up and talked about most Both the cream of the crop and better than SPYD SPYD Vs. I like SPYD. 57. We all know they are very close in a lot of ways including 46 overlapping holdings. Dividend Equity ETF and Vanguard’s High Dividend Yield ETF. com Skip to main navigation VYM is just a version of Total Stock Market minus any company with decent growth. dividend stocks. VYM: Head-To-Head ETF Comparison The table below compares many ETF metrics between HDV and VYM. I've always seen VYM has a more diversified dividend fund than SCHD and I hold both. 29% vs 0. A slower growers would be HDV,SPYD,DJD. Or check it out in the app stores A better comparison would be VYM vs VIG vs VTI; and as you can see, results would be rather (standard deviation) of US high dividend yield funds like VYM, SCHD, HDV, SPYD, SPHD and compare them to any S&P 500 fund (or insert any US total To understand what I'm saying take a look at the Vanguard dividend schedule in the link below as an example. This places VYM in the 69th percentile among funds in the category. I'm not the smartest person when it comes to investing. Diversification: Diversifying across multiple dividend ETFs can help spread risk. Is VYM a bad choice - absolutly not. VYM – Comparing Vanguard’s 2 Popular Dividend ETF’s; SPYD vs. 07% expense ratio, which is higher than SCHD's 0. 26 per share I would say JEPI would not be a viable investment from the perspective of consistent monthly income. Compare fees, performance, dividend yield, holdings, technical indicators, and many other metrics to make a better investment decision. Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. e. It tracks the S&P 500 High Dividend Index, which is the 80 stocks out of 'the 500' with the highest dividend yields. 17 Also, is there any reason why you would invest in VYM or HDV over SPY/SPHD since both of them have higher yields (I could see investing in SPHD over SPY due to lower volatility and lower P/E)? VYM vs SCHD . VYM’s largest holding is international View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Also, is there any reason why you would invest in VYM or HDV over SPY/SPHD since both of them have higher yields (I could Good summary of pros and cons: https://seekingalpha. These values are calculated using daily returns over the previous 12 months. Reddit investment advice is one big bandwagon if you haven’t picked up on it yet. Its a steady stream of cash and keep the entire VYM positions while goes up slowly. Value stocks are those with 'low price' compared to earnings, or 'book value', or sales. Schd dividend growth it look beautiful, SPYD dividends are all over the place. r/StockMarket. Discuss topics related to Personal Finance, Money, Budgets, Careers, Investing, Retirement, and FIRE Everyone loves schd but I was looking at vym and it seems that they have similar expense ratios, and while schd has a higher yield it’s top ten holdings are much more concentrated making Vym seem a little more diversified. Ultimately, I decide to go with SPYD and got in around $23 per share. I’m not sure what your source on this is, but I’m fairly sure that on a total return basis (as in including dividends) sp500 should still have still slightly higher returns, and that’s considering that right now we are at end of a massive secular run I. VYM do a review once per year and in 400 stocks the have is crap. Im sure thats Spyd UCITS ETF in Europe is the equivalent of NOBL over the pond. All those are very low fees, from 0. VYM has returned 9. I also think I can diversify it by investing in ETFs such as VNQ and SPYD which has more focus on REIT and Financial sector. Check out the side-by-side comparison table of SCHD vs. SPHD is the Invesco S&P 500 High Dividend Low Volatility ETF. But they have very different paremeters. The S&P 500 is not exactly a fair comparison to VTV or VYM because the S&P 500 is a large cap blend portfolio meaning it has both value and growth stocks. Overview Holdings Performance ESG New. VYM has a higher dividend yield so instinctly I feel like going with that. Unpopular opinion, but I don’t see a major problem owning SCHD, SPHD, SPYD and VYM. Adding something like VYM, a very popular ETF with more recognisable companies, would be plenty of diversification. Also, SCHD vs VYM previous 2019 was almost similar. 98% vs 3. 96%, P/E 15. I personally prefer FUSD. If you are dividend investing, the two best dividend ETFs to pair with SCHD (in my opinion) are DGRO and DGRW. This is why you see out performance with the S&P 500, it can invest in other Growth vs. 20% expenses ratio vs . Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) are two of the U. VYM – Methodology. Retired Investor. Reply reply FatMikey777 • Right on sounds good! Reply reply More replies More replies More replies. HDV vs. Adding to that, VYM has an expense ration of . Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Just for fun simulate income in 20 yrs of those etf's, SPYD yield high today, but in 20 yrs SCHD I dont know which website to believe re: Div growth since the numbers dont match not sure why. makes no sense to hold more than 4 etf's. However, VYM holds a little more than 4x the amount of stocks that SCHD holds, so VYM is a little more “recession proof. 22% expense ratio. He does talk about ETFs in the "Clash of Cultures", and his advice on them is the same as index funds. It would be better to keep investingin schd because of greater returns. On the other hand, VYM applies more weight to Utilities, Energy, and Medicine. Below "Portfolio 1"= Vanguard High Dividend Yield (VYM) , "Portfolio 2" = SPYD SCHD has a higher dividend vs VYM SCHD has doubled the returns of VYM SCHD fell 5% less than VYM During march 2020. Or check it out in the but I might prefer VYM in a little slower condition. Reply reply More replies Hello r/dividends, I am seeking some advice on diversification, growth vs yield, risk, et cetera. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Now, about quarterly vs monthly and more compounding if we are talking about equal yield, and everything the same only difference is paying monthly vs quarterly. belangp • I have both. About Ok, first let me explain that I really don't mind a speed performance decrease on what I'm about to ask. I’m not sure when but I noticed FDVV lowered the expense ratio to . SPYD has a better or you can say higher dividend yield with 6. VYM vs SCHD Brokerage I know SCHD is loved here however I do own 419 shares of VYM. 01 percent lower mer, and is around 2. Make it a core dividend play next to DGRO. Only reason you would pick SPYD is for the ~4-5% dividend yield but if you want to do that pick DIVO which has outperformed SPYD and grows much better while also having the In fact, the majority of my portfolio is in it. Despite the difference, both funds are considered low-cost compared to the broader market, where average expense ratios usually range from As you can see, Broadcom also finds a place in VYM’s top 10 holdings. But is my opinion. Ymmv, ianal, ianafa, I am not a cat. Lately from posts ive been reading some reviews I've seen. Observe the sweet spot for yields with low risk of cutting dividends is around 3. 06 is a considerable difference given similar performance. Historically value has outperformed, but that hasn't been true during this past cycle. All of that aside, since VIG and DGRO are basically the same concept. VIG vs VYM aren’t comparable. However, SPHD has better growth in price appreciation. Its 3. VYM is most similiar to SCHD of the funds you have listed. Please explain what’s better I would go VYM or SCHD because of the expense and all "high div" indexes tend to Rich-Ad-4240 • Additional comment actions. VYM Any opinions on the better ETF, All i know is SPHD is . It shouldn't be too surprising that a fund that is essentially a subset of a larger fund is correlated with that larger fund. Or check it out in the app stores VYM vs. SPYD launched in 2015. I do agree wiyh that. By most accounts it still made anyone holding and buying a great return. SCHD might VYM is a pure income play, is a "VTI of dividends" , vanguard does change indexes many times, I would say vanguard tends to be too conservative for my taste, SCHD surpase VYM in the contest. What’s most important is that you choose one and stick with it for the Never Ever trust any Reddit or other Expert avice All are same tracking S&P 500. 06, buy in is a little lower SCHD. 97%, P/E 11. HCIC and HCICW are buys here when compared to TSP valuation Currently, I only own SCHD and SCHY as long term ETFs for dividends. com Open. That's all. But anyway - one While sympathetic to their case, one factor that keeps me invested in VYM instead of switching to VTI or VOO is the large divergence in price vs. Those rankings, however, are based solely on quantitative Most game engines can’t actually handle this kind of speed. It seems VYM is recommended often but in comparison threads it doesn't seem to perform well. SPYD: Head-To-Head ETF Comparison The table below compares many ETF metrics between SCHD and SPYD. HDV is top loaded on oil and SPYD has a nice dividend but slower growth. Also they track is longer. In my dividend ETF rankings, VYM lands at #2 and VIG comes in at #3, behind only the SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 High Dividend ETF (SPYD). VOOV is a 'value' S&P 500 fund. Compare fees, performance, dividend yield, holdings, technical indicators, and many other metrics to make VYM vs. Let's make money together! SCHD is better than VYM, the screening is way better. consultant, Boglehead, and Oxford comma advocate. My VYM position is pretty high, but I'm going to buy some SCHD to hold and compare bother over the next five years, or so to see if the I'm trying to find difference between holding SCHD vs SPYD. 70% Health Care is high at 15. I keep two for better growth and two for better yield. 75%, P/E 14. However, both funds are considered low-cost compared to the broader market, where average expense ratios usually range from 0. I own stocks in these sectors so I'm not too concerned about it. VYM is the only quality (balance sheet) neutral ETF here, and its only real identity seems to be yield. Income: While high dividend yield is essential for your goal, it's also crucial to consider the growth potential of the ETF. SCHD's methodology states that it will select stocks with at least a 10-year history of paying dividends and uses a fundamental screens (cash-flow to debt ratio, ROE, dividend yield, and dividend growth rate). I took had SPYD, SPHD, and VTI all on my watchlist. Lastly I would like to include an S&P 500 ETF for If you like the idea of dividens VYM, VIG, SCHD, SCHY are solid dividends. Compare SPYD and VYM ETFs on current and historical performance, AUM, flows, holdings, costs, ESG ratings, and many other metrics. The ratio of SCHD to VYM is simply an expression of how much you believe in SCHD's more rigorous screening process. Vym has around a percent lower dividend yield, a 0. Just View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Monthly dividend + I like the holdings SPHD have, but SPYD was cheaper. The ideal combination would be for SPYD: Yields 6. Since inception of SPYD never beats SCHD. Another option is to invest in two VYM and VUG with dividends and growth balanced View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. VYM is tilted more towards the value factor. Or check it out in the Compare VOO and VYM ETFs on current and historical performance, AUM, flows, holdings, costs, ESG ratings, and many other metrics. The chart below compares the historical Sharpe Ratios of VYM and SCHD, offering insights into how both investments have performed under varying market conditions. 77% dividend increase per year. 02% while SPHD has 5. SCHD is due for a capital gains distribution eventually vs VYM -5 if your thinking for tax purposes. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. HDV - Vanguard Dividend ETF vs. Check performance in seeking alpha or in portfolio visualizer. I've been investing in VYM longer than schd. They only have a 20% overlap so it seems to make since. The dividend isn't high enough to justify its underperformance. 01, 2022 8:00 AM ET iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV), SPYD 10 Comments 14 Likes. Get (and give!) advice on investment portfolios and financial planning goals for retirement (401k, Roth, IRA, HSA) and taxable investing accounts, particularly stock and bond mutual funds and ETFs - learn tips for tax efficiency and other account optimization strategies. I am focusing more on latter two. 40% ish into QYLD/QYLG and the last 5% I use to play with theta strategies mainly credit spreads and condors. Almost all of the holdings in SCHD are included in VYM. VYM ETF Comparison Analysis | etf. I turn to books youtube and people for advice. In addition, the fund only has 104 stocks in it altogether. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on VYM heavily lags SCHD, DGRO, DGRW, SPY, VTI, etc in total returns. Some others might be SPYD, SPHD, NOBL, SDY, DVY, VIG and HDV. 30%. I do have SCHD and DGRO, but in the future I will go back to VYM, I had it, but the faster horse here is SCHD. 0. So SCHD has only 100 holdings compared to VYM's 447, but 89% of those 100 are in VYM. 9%. You want STABILITY besides yield. Open comment sort options. I keep seeing recommendations for SCHD, but when looking around, I found SPYD had a better dividend ratio. com/article/4540408-schd-vs-vym-etf-better-buy. Although SCHD has had better performance recently, 40% of it is concentrated into only 10 stocks. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS VIG and DGRO are nearly identical with DGRO having more companies because of the 5 yr vs 10 yr dividend requirement. r/ETFs. Would you suggest holding or selling to transfer this to SCHD? Cost basis is $89 I would not recommend changing ETFs just because a sub on reddit is fanatical about it. As seen, since 2013, SPHD vs. CGDV is a solid choice. I currently own both, but I am likely going to sell my VOO and put it in VYM. SPYD VYM PEY SCHD Archived post. 0% current yield and 12% compounded returns since inception. Tello is lower priority, use app for wifi calling, very flexible pricing by needs, online. 06, I am now actively adding FDVV over SCHD. SCHD has 105 holdings and VYM has 444. VIG’s comparables are, for example, DGRW and DGRO. I do like VYM,SCHD,DGRO,VIG for income and some growth. 5% higher return this year. You might have a personal preference, but it’s all the same thing. In the EU, the choice for a decent dividend etf largely comes down to SPYD(better upfront yield) vs FUSD(better diversification, much better dividend growth). Expand user menu Open settings menu. Hello, all! Many of you have recommended VTI (or a comparable total US index) when composing a well-balanced portfolio. Schd is better for my purpose. I say VYM, both are good but VYM has 10X more assets and has battled through one recession. I’m long VYMI for some ex-us blue chip exposure. There is about a 25% overlap between the 2 but there’s enough of a difference, they both have performed well, and the nature of the role there holdings play in a portfolio I’m not against a little diversification. That 20% VUG Will be maybe, HDV 10% Spyd 10% . I have about $10k in this, and honestly was thinking about selling it and to add to my AMZN/AAPL shares. The Vanguard High Dividend Yield Index ETF (VYM) and the Schwab U. VOO vs. 75 HDV: Yields 4. VYM is more heavy in PG, and more companies I like. I like SCHD but it is more concentrated in its top holdings, so you'd be giving up some diversification. If you look at the charts SCHD heavily outperforms SPYD. 5% however the etf is a great value tilt and great growth. DGRO is a more " open arms" etf for dividend growth. You may all now begin my crucifixion. schh 15% voo 15% schd 15% vxus 15% schp 10% vym 10% edv 5% idlv 5% ushy 5% Spyd 5% Schd and Voo are still in contention with each other. It has the big tech dividend payers (which double as growth), dividend growth, pays dividends monthly, has a hefty healthcare allocation which is only going to continue growing with the aging boomer population, and, sure the 0. VYM - SPDR Dividend ETF The criteria to be added in SCHD screens for better quality stocks while VYM is looking for higher yield. As mentioned, Capital Group is a newcomer to ETFs but they have a long history with mutual funds (AIVSX goes back to the 1930s!) and are found in many 401k plans. 01, which is lower than the VYM Sharpe Ratio of 1. As the name suggests, If this is everything you plan to put in your portfolio then 2 would likely be optimal and provide plenty of diversification. VYM has paid an annual dividend for 15 years in a row and increased its annual payout for 12 straight years. Spyd has a higher yield , the mer ratio is the same and is less expensive per share. I chose VYM because it’s more diversified, but I do know SCHD has a higher yield and better 10y past performance. Take a look at the holdings and you will understand why it's not growing. You want just growth? VTI, SPY, QQQ pick your total market of choices. But you need to understand that it is very heavily Usually young people chase total return more than dividends. The point with dividends is not to loose principal. . I’ve bought these three ETFs (SCHD,SPYD,VYM) and I didn’t realize they all do almost the same thing. Maybe some VPU utilities and VDC consuner staples yield decent and consistent dividends. Spyd dropped a ton during the covid dip and was a bit slower to regain its momentum. 145 votes, 137 comments. VYM has utilities and more energy. I just started investing somewhat recently, so I could sell my VYM and buy SCHD, but I would have a small amount of taxable gains. com’s ETF comparison tool and look at side-by-side data on any two ETFs in the entire investment universe. Share Sort by: Please note that as a topic focused subreddit we have higher posting standards than much of Reddit: 1) Please direct all advice requests and beginner questions to the stickied daily threads. 17. com and the topics thereof. Or coke vs Pepsi. To an individual single you have to make more than 40k in dividends which is more than a 1M with VYM. NOBL invests in high-quality S&P 500 stocks that have consistently increased dividends for 25 years. The Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM 0. This article compares SCHD vs VYM — Schwab’s U. 5 x price of spyd. Just look at all and compare sector allocation, market cap allocation and whatever else you find important. However, in a 10-15 year period, DGRO’s dividend growth rate catches up to vym and eventually overcomes with its dividend growth rate being much higher. VYM is interesting but I will probably will not add it. 06 for schd/vym. fundamentals. Or If you want dividends, the only dvd etf to consider is schd or vym. 95. Reply reply quietWolves • our community is the best way to get help on Reddit with your questions about investing with Fidelity I would do dgrw. 06% expense ratio. I have done a fair amount of research on both VYM and VIG and IMO they are both appealing. Hi I am working on a strategy for investing and part of this is dividend etfs. Feb. I keep low allocation to DGRO and heavy 50/50 SCHD/VYM. 06 to 0. Units, Warrants and the best DD on Reddit. Comparison of Dividends VYM VS SCHD Both expense ratio at . I want to retire early with this money. I wouldn’t do SPYD though it has marginally better yield than SCHD and a fraction of the growth. Spyd could be better for other people. 33%. " But since both are algorithmically VYM vs SCHD: Which Dividend ETF Should You Buy in 2025? 10 hours ago - 24/7 Wall Street. You can use those ETFs for influence, based on what kind of dividend strategy you want to follow (yield Vs growth) but for the same money you put into those ETFs you could easily buy into a company for higher dividends. S. Both have great track records in this area, with VYM boasting a slightly longer one. Investing Group. They are closely matched and are similarly low-cost. -based corporations that have generally both grown their stock price and sustained high dividends. Im still trying to figure out which is better in the long run. Best. 3% E Ratio, so you'd think SCHD is better, but then theres VYM. 18%, P/E 16. their mutual funds are OK, relatively speaking, if you can avoid the higher-fee shares. 7% yield is roughly double that of the S&P 500 making it a nice addition to a bigger portfolio. HDV: Yields 4. VYM vs VIG: Index Strategy. VYM also is not "the market. sp500 outperformance is almost always during prolonged bear markets and crashes. Distributions are not drastically different. However, its expense ratio is much larger when compared to SCHD and VYM (0. 2 High-Yield Dividend ETFs to Buy to Generate Passive Income 1/11/2025 - The Motley Fool. SCHD follows an index, the Dow US Dividend 100. SPHD . 06%) and that usually takes it out of the serious discussion on best dividend ETF. Both are passively-managed index ETFs popular with dividend investors and retirees looking to Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. So I believe, based on data for 2 past years, that nearly all dividend ETF’s with yield around 3-4% (SPYD, SCHD, SPHD) were the best choice. The 10 years dividend increase vs the 5 years increase of DGRO sucks. I’m new here and was curious what your thoughts were. "income" can just as easily be achieved by selling shares as it is turning off the reinvestment of dividends both funds have pretty similar returns and behaviors; VIG gets a bit more returns from price appreciation schd is a bit more yield oriented. SPYD vs. VYM's ALTAR Score™ is approximately 0. At the very end I sucumb to get more value and stability, so I have VYM,SCHD,DGRO . You will also find 'Growth' S&P 500 funds which generally have high prices. The only hook of VIG alwsys is high quality and downturn protection, SPYD vs SCHD? Own both or Visible is basically a subset of Verizon: lower priority, 400mbps speed limit, not quite as much support phone wise, online, can join "families" for lower rates yet individual billing. SPHD: A closer look at their holdings. Also you can see how price and 312 subscribers in the optimizedportfolio community. Some say its a bit bloated ans that Vanguard doesn't rebalance it enough but its had 9 years of dividend growth and also decent fund growth. In theory, you could find other funds that follow the same index. VYM is more diversified/has I respect VIG and VYMI but the prescreening SCHD does and the ultimate market cap weighting at the end makes me put most of my dividend money into SCHD. SCHD vs SPYD . market’s largest and most successful dividend ETFs. You do better with a better-curated SCHD. I do invest in this etf. Given that the ten-year past performance of VTI and VYM are very similar, I wondered if any of you would ever recommend subbing VTI for VYM in a 3-4 holding portfolio consisting of (VTI/VYM), intl stocks, and total bonds. I guess I just picked stocks randomly at the time and didn’t really realize what I had VYM: Yields 3. There will always be an infinite amount of strategies to lose money (especially investing in concentrated sectors of the economy), but broad, cheap expense, and passively managed ETFs and funds is the easy way to get fair share returns of the market. 57, which is higher than the SCHD Sharpe Ratio of 0. SPYG tracks the stocks in the S&P 500 that have been growing revenues at a high rate. 5% over the same time horizon. VYM is good but there is an overlap between SCHD and VYM that includes 89 stocks. VYM CAGR 6. By holding all three in equal amounts, your dividend portfolio is diversified by how it chooses dividend stocks (eg focusing on yield or growth), how it’s weighted (eg dividend weighted vs market weighted) and stock eligibility (eg SCHD requires companies pay I’m only 21 and currently have about 20% of my $4. VYM has been the better performer over the past three years, but I’ll give the edge to SCHD here based on its better performance over the longer five- and 10-year time spans. spyd vs schd has a lot more variance in holdings and performance book price doesnt matter. It's a decent income ETF, but if a company was big enough to be part of SP500 and raise dividends for 25 consecutive years, you can bet the strong growth days are long gone. SCHD is heavily weighted in the Information Technology and Financials sectors (~20% in each). Sell Side Consensus Rating Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. SCHD, I find SCHD has higher historical returns and current distribution yield. Divo obviously returned more over the past 5 years but I'm not looking for capital appreciation. SPYD and SPHD. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Which is better? It seems to me that VYM earns slightly better dividends and also has 400 companies vs SCHD’s 100. See which holdings any two equity ETFs have in common SCHD only had 103 holdings while VYM has 444. I would like feed back. 06%), expense ratio is similar, and the charts are nearly identical. I don’t know which one to go with and was hoping you all can provide angles to help me decide Thanks 🙏 VIG vs. Ended up liking VYM so much the defensive dividend ETFs in my portfolio are now 1/3 SCHD, 1/3 VYM, and 1/3 SPYD, VIG, & DGRO. SCHD – Methodology. It’s just to much communication to fast. In my case I decided to have both, but give 5% or more weight to SCHD. 06% compared to . You can play around with % and 4 etf's, more etf's is not more diversification. 75. Let's look at the Vanguard High Dividend Yield Index as an example (VHYAX for the mutual fund version and VYM for the ETF version). If you’re in America, SCHD is the better choice compared to SPYD(better dividend growth, comparable yield, better diversification). Is there a VYM vs SCHD. Reply reply SPYD vs VOO comments. SPYD I am continuing to add little by little, but if SPHD dips back to around the $27 range, I might look to add. Top. The current VYM Sharpe Ratio is 1. I might still add QQQ in place of one of them for some growth. 34%. 52%. They are, I believe VYM, VIG, DGRO, SCHD are the top " plain old" dividend ETF's, I would say vanguard team is falling behind SCHD and DGRO. 55% per year compared to VYM’s 6. The next chart compares their performance since SPHD’s inception in 2013, benchmarked by the S&P 500. After looking at low cost ETF options such as VYM and combining them along with Dividend Appreciation Index Fund ETF such as VIG or DGRO seemed like a good option to me. 652 subscribers in the TheMoneyMix community. Low expense ratio's, large blue chip holdings, etc. 10, beyond that is craving Reddit investment advice is one big bandwagon if you haven’t picked up on it yet. VYM has a 23% concentration in its top 10 and holds 444 stocks. Also Schd has a significant weighting of Verizon and Cisco which have solid dividends but lackluster growth. DGRO is 2-2. market’s largest and most su SPHD vs. As someone who used to own VYM & VIG, you likely will want to stick with individual stocks. I really like the holdings in SPYD, however Financials and Utilities combine for over 50% of it. VYM is also heavily into Financials (~20%), but Info Tech is only 8. I hold VHYAX, which is the mutual fund form of VYM, instead of the ETF Ended up liking VYM so much the defensive dividend ETFs in my portfolio are now 1/3 SCHD, 1/3 VYM, and 1/3 SPYD, VIG, & DGRO. Don't mention overlapping. I began investing a couple months ago; my largest position by a wide margin was SPYD, but I sold out of that today because I made a $500 gain on it since January and I have seen other funds like VYM being praised more highly. New SPYD, and DIV Reply SPY tracks the S&P 500. Is there any way to have a page refresh automatically after each change so SCHD and VYM use slightly different methodologies that has resulted in slight performance differences (especially since 2020). r/Guiltygear • VYM vs SCHD: Which Dividend ETF Should You Buy in 2025? 10 hours ago - 24/7 Wall Street. SCHD 5yr CAGR 13% and has outperformed every other similar fund. 07% while VOO SPYD vs. VYM holds more companies (443 VYM vs 100 SCHD at the moment) to diversify away some risk. 15%. I am thinking 20% schd, 8% spyd, 8% dgro, 8% vym and 6% jepi . Everyone loves schd but I was looking at vym and it seems that they have similar expense ratios, and while schd has a higher yield it’s top ten holdings are much more concentrated making Vym seem a little more diversified. 11 SPYD VS ???? Seeking Advice Hi All, Spyd is perfectly fine - Reddit gets hung up on “the best” or fetishizing their own picks. Both come from renowned having VYM and SCHD is more than enough for a dividend portfolio, they are obsess here with putting together 12 etf's, the overlapping and rebalancing is a real nightmare there. 89% per year, compared to VYM only growing about 10% per year. VYM vs. 75 So that means the value of a share of VOO is increasing faster than Spyd, but spyd is returning higher dividends? So itd be fair to say if your looking for dividend income spyd is good but if your looking for value increase VOO is good. Home Depot (), Pepsi, and AbbVie are also present in the top 10 for each fund. I was thinking of adding 2-5 ETFs of most likely equal distribution. Good for you to want to invest early. Thoughts? -the two I’m stuck deciding between : VYM vs SPYD. 06 SPHD: Yields 5. the other. Still if it can hold a high yield of ~8% with some sort of dividend growth it FDVV is Fidelity’s version. HDV: Comparing The Spider And iShares High Dividend ETFs. Well it isn't January of 2022 just yet, but given the distribution on 08/01/2021 is a mere $0. Technicals Database My VYM holding has done WAY better than my SCHD this year. ” That desicion is on you. Members Online. Yet I see lots of people going for SCHD. The SCHD is still king in this category. I like ETFs that have been around longer. 29 vs. VYM vs SCHD comments. I am currently buying VYM monthly and thinking about adding in SPYD into the mix. SPHD will succumb to a larger decline as it is a stock etf and we entering what many believe to be a a recession. I actually am more of a fan of VIG than VYM based solely on their holdings but feel free to enlighten me if I am missing something. 5k portfolio dedicated to VYM. It's dividend growth rate is also a lot slower and even has a lower yield. VYM has a higher dividend but SCHD has a higher yield. 06% expense ratio, which is lower than VYMI's 0. I would pair with SCHD or VYM. A community by and for dividend growth investors. VYM. Best Dividend ETFs For Asset Preservation In 2025 Ranked 1/13/2025 - Seeking Alpha. I do not care about taxes. Dollar for dollar you will get more dividends with SCHD, based on recent dividend performance. The estructure is different. SCHD has almost 2x technology weight vs VYM. Up to you which exposure works better for your portfolio. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. The “high precision mouse input” change allows the system to “handle” this communication speed, Which means smoother, faster aiming. Qdiv has a . It compares fees, performance, dividend yield, holdings, technical indicators, and many other metrics that help make better ETF investing decisions. Personally I am 60% ish in to a mix of VTI, VYM, VIG. While that is still higher than SCHD’s . 52 VYM: Yields 3. 100% best comment! I am ridding VUG 20 % SCHD 30% VYM 30% DGRO 20 % VUG is my " money making " scooping up that growth, at some point, I will slowly drain VUG into more dividend ETFs when aproaching 65 years old. 451K subscribers in the dividends community. The dividend is paid every three months and the last ex-dividend date was Dec 20, 2024. if you have $100 dollars to spend: owning 1 share of a $100 company that goes to 110 will net you more in returns than buying 10 shares of a $10 that only goes to $10. Only you know how much risk you can take. r/dividends • 3 SPYD is a high-dividend ETF. Thanks I have both schd and vym. 28% expense ratio is high compared to a passive fund but it’s not high in absolute terms. I own HDV, SPYD, SCHD and VYM. 86 per share in the past year. I found an ETF called Spyd and it basically has the same yield and a way lower ER. A subreddit for the website www. It honestly just hasn't really performed as well as I thought it would in this market, pretty modest gains as the rest of the market explodes. Click here to read the full analysis. 35% and paid $1. SPYD will continue dropping as well but being a bond etf it leads SPHD and with yields rising bond yields will SCHD grows an average of 16. If I were you, I would do SCHD 40% VYM 40%, VOO 20% . Just looking for some insight based on advice yestersay ill be dumping some cash in one of the two soon. will go down less than the rest. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Overall was looking at VIG vs VYM: ETF Comparison Tool Investors can use etf. 9% over the past 10 years (as of October 31). VYMI - Expense Ratio Comparison VYM has a 0. SPYV tracks the stocks in the S&P 500 that have a low price compared to current earnings Methodology. While your age, financial goals, account type, etc should factor into your final decision, either fund will serve you well if focused on the long term and Using an etf comparison tool to see overlap, about 84% of SCHD's holdings are held in VYM. Seeking Alpha has different numbers. VYM vs SCHD. Since I don’t know a ton about what’s offered on the euro market I’ll suggest using your brokers Leg into SPYD while I drops as yields rise. 06%), expense ratio is similar, and the charts are Skip to main content. VYM follows a different index, the FTSE High Dividend Yield. r/investing A chip A close button. It seems like SPYD wins the battle in the areas that are most View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) This is the first pure high yield play on this list. bzpflv nqzv njgif voarzr vezjc vtn dhrefsu anlrgf lmvybd oap